The white stone John Minor Wisdom courthouse in New Orleans, home of the Fifth Circuit, with a colonnade and a US flag on the roof
Photo: ajay_suresh / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0, modified

Design2 min read

The bag-fee rule that never reached a single fare search

FlightCal team

In April 2024, the Department of Transportation finished a rule that would have put bag fees beside every fare in a search. It never reached one. Airlines and online ticket agents would have had to show the first and second checked bag, carry-on, change and cancellation fees the first time a search displayed a price. Those fees "cannot be displayed through a hyperlink," it added.

DOT put a number on the problem. It estimated that travelers overpay about $543 million a year in fees, for example by paying a higher fee to check a bag at the airport after being surprised by it.

A card reading $543M: a year in fees travelers overpay, by DOT's 2024 estimate. The rule was stayed in July 2024 and vacated in February 2026.
DOT counted the $543 million as a transfer from airlines to travelers, not a cost. Source: 89 FR 34620; Fifth Circuit, 2026.

Airlines had until April 30, 2025 to comply, and on July 29, 2024, a Fifth Circuit panel put the rule on hold.

It died on a procedural point. DOT had used a study by Nicholas Rupp to estimate how much fee information matters to travelers, and never opened that study to public comment. A January 2025 panel said DOT could write rules like this one but kept it blocked over the study. When the full court heard the case, DOT conceded the violation and said, for the first time, that it would be "happy to start all over again." A concurring opinion noted the department now served a different president. On February 3, 2026, the court vacated the entire rule.

In July, DOT restored the 2011 standard. The first screen that quotes a fare must say that bag fees may apply and where to find them. It doesn't have to say what they are.

Why FlightCal shows the fee

FlightCal doesn't sell tickets, but it does show which fare looks cheapest. Since version 1.02.0 in October, checked fares show baggage fees when the airline provides them. Since 1.03.0, allowances show per person. A fare that is $40 cheaper (an example figure) stops being cheaper once a $45 bag fee (also an example) is added. Showing the fee lets that comparison happen before booking.

The limit is in the release note itself: "when the airline provides them." The requirement to put that fee beside every fare is gone, and DOT told the court it is writing a new one.

Sources

  1. Enhancing Transparency of Airline Ancillary Service Fees (89 FR 34620, April 30, 2024)Accessed November 9, 2026
  2. Airlines for America v. U.S. Department of Transportation, No. 24-60231 (5th Cir. Feb. 3, 2026) (en banc)Accessed November 9, 2026
  3. Increasing Flexibility on Disclosure of Airline Ancillary Fees (DOT final rule, Docket DOT-OST-2026-0199)Accessed November 9, 2026
  4. FlightCal on the App StoreAccessed November 9, 2026

Make room for a trip worth watching.

Download FlightCal, set your places, dates, and price, and let FlightCal watch the fares.

Get FlightCal

All posts