
Ralph Nader got bumped in 1972. A 1968 auction idea was the fix
US airlines bumped more than 82,000 passengers with confirmed reservations in 1972. One was Ralph Nader. On April 28 he was turned away from Allegheny flight 864, Washington to Hartford, where he was due at a noon rally. An hour before departure the airline had confirmed 107 reservations for 100 seats.
Nader asked the agents to find someone who would give up a seat voluntarily. They refused. He turned down the $32.41 Allegheny tendered as denied-boarding compensation and sued for fraud, arguing the airline never disclosed that it oversold on purpose. In 1976 the Supreme Court ruled that his fraud claim did not have to wait for the Civil Aeronautics Board, the airline regulator. Its opinion put the 1972 bumping rate at 5.4 passengers per 10,000 domestic boardings.
The auction in a two-page note
The fix Nader asked for was already in print. In May 1968 the economist Julian Simon published "An Almost Practical Solution to Airline Overbooking", two pages in the Journal of Transport Economics and Policy. Give each passenger on a full flight a bid form asking the smallest sum they would take to wait. "The lowest bidder is paid in cash and given a ticket for the next flight." Simon guessed airlines would find it did "not seem decorous."
Alfred Kahn, another economist, became chairman of that board in 1977. In 1978 the board rewrote its oversales rule to require airlines to ask for volunteers before bumping anyone. It also set involuntary compensation at 200% of the fare, with a $75 minimum and a $400 maximum.
That requirement is still federal law, now 14 CFR 250.2b. The gate agent who raises the offer until a hand goes up is running Simon's auction out loud.

Involuntary bumping is now rare. In the last quarter of 2024 the 10 US airlines that report to DOT bumped 0.25 passengers per 10,000 against their will, about a twentieth of the 1972 rate.
When it does happen, the rule sets the floor for the bargaining. On a domestic trip, if the airline can't get you there within two hours of your original arrival, it owes 400% of the one-way fare, up to $2,150. That number is worth knowing before you take the first voucher at the gate. It is what the airline would owe you if nobody volunteered and you were bumped.
Sources
- Nader v. Allegheny Airlines, Inc., 426 U.S. 290 (1976)Accessed November 18, 2026
- Julian Simon's "Almost Practical Solution to Airline Overbooking" (Conversable Economist)Accessed November 18, 2026
- Julian Simon: Irreplaceable Economist, Irreplaceable Man (The Independent Review, Fall 2023)Accessed November 18, 2026
- Airline Passenger Denied Boarding: Rules and Regulations (CRS Insight IN10693)Accessed November 18, 2026
- 14 CFR 250.2b, Carriers to request volunteers for denied boardingAccessed November 18, 2026
- 14 CFR 250.5, Amount of denied boarding compensation for passengers denied boarding involuntarilyAccessed November 18, 2026
- Air Travel Consumer Report: December 2024, Full Year 2024 NumbersAccessed November 18, 2026
